Secondhand Cashmere: How to Check Quality and Authenticity (A Genuinely Honest Guide From Someone Who Handles These Every Week)

Cashmere is one of those materials that genuinely rewards the secondhand buyer. A good piece from a heritage brand, bought used for €50, will outlast three cheap new sweaters bought at full price. I know this because I handle knitwear every week at Revaleur, and cashmere is consistently the category where the secondhand market makes the most sense. The problem is the market is also full of rubbish. Mislabelled blends, overly processed fibres, synthetic fakes wearing a "100% cashmere" tag. So before you spend a euro, here is exactly what I look at, and what you should too.

Why buying secondhand cashmere is worth it (when you know what you are doing)

A new Grade A cashmere sweater from a proper heritage brand costs between €300 and €600. The same piece, bought secondhand in excellent condition, might cost you €40 to €120. That is not a compromise, that is a bargain, as long as the piece is genuine and the quality holds up. Good quality cashmere actually gets softer with age and wear. That is one of the things that makes it so interesting in the secondhand market: a well cared for piece from fifteen years ago can feel better than something new from a lesser brand. The key is knowing which pieces those are.

If you want to understand the broader case for buying knitwear secondhand, I wrote a full guide on how to style vintage knitwear in 2026 which covers the quality angle in detail.

Start here: reading the label

The care label is your first filter, and it matters more than any physical test. The rule is simple. The label should say "100% cashmere." Nothing more, nothing less. If it says anything vague like "cashmere feel," "cashmere touch," or "cashmere like," put it back. That is marketing language, not fibre content, and it usually means little or no actual cashmere in the garment. If it says "cashmere blend" without stating the exact percentages, that is also a red flag. Legitimate blends declare themselves clearly, for example "70% cashmere, 30% merino wool." If there is no label at all, be very cautious.

Beyond the fibre content, look for:

  • Country of origin for the fibre. Mongolia is considered the gold standard for raw cashmere fibre. Scotland and Italy are the benchmark countries for spinning and manufacturing. Seeing "made in Scotland" or "spun in Italy" alongside a heritage brand name is a genuinely positive sign.
  • Ply count. Two ply cashmere uses two strands twisted together, giving the garment more body, durability and warmth than single ply. Some labels state this. If they do, two ply is what you want for a sweater or cardigan you plan to wear regularly.
  • Grade. Most brands do not advertise fibre grade on the label, but some heritage producers do. Grade A cashmere measures 14 to 15.5 microns in fibre diameter and is the finest available. Grade B runs from 16 to 19 microns. Grade C, at 30 microns or above, approaches the coarseness of regular wool and is not worth chasing in the secondhand market.

One important clarification: a "100% cashmere" label is a necessary condition but not a sufficient one. It tells you the fibre is cashmere. It says nothing about grade, ply, or how the garment was constructed. That is where the physical tests come in.

The touch test: what real cashmere feels like under your fingers

This is where most guides start, and there is good reason for it. Genuine, good quality cashmere has a feel that is very hard to fake once you have experienced it. It is soft without being slippery. Dense and substantial despite being lightweight. When you rub a small section between your fingers, there should be a slight resistance, what knitters call "bite," that tells you the yarn has proper structure. If the fabric feels almost artificially smooth and slides between your fingers like silk, it has likely been over processed, which makes it feel great in the shop and disappointing after a few wears.

The cheek or chin test is not silly. Run the fabric lightly across your cheek or the inside of your wrist. Real cashmere should feel immediately comfortable against sensitive skin. If it itches or scratches at all, something is wrong. Either the fibre grade is too low, there are non cashmere fibres in the blend, or the garment has been poorly stored and the fibres have matted.

One thing to watch with secondhand pieces specifically: sometimes a cashmere sweater feels a little stiff when you first pick it up, especially if it has been stored flat for a long time. That is not necessarily a dealbreaker. Give it a gentle stretch and a feel. Quality fibres tend to wake up quickly.

The look test: what to see when you hold it up

Hold the piece at eye level and look across the surface of the fabric in good light. You are looking for a small, even amount of surface fluff, roughly 1 to 2mm. That slight fuzziness is a sign of quality cashmere fibre. If you see much more than 2mm of fluff, or if the surface looks fluffy and chaotic rather than even, treat it as suspicious. Conversely, if the surface is completely flat and smooth with no texture at all, that can also indicate a synthetic blend or heavily processed fibre.

Now hold it up to a window or a lamp. Good cashmere should show a consistent, even knit pattern when backlit. If you can see thin patches, areas where the knit looks stretched or uneven, or small holes beginning to form, those are signs of wear or poor original quality. Pay particular attention to the elbows, underarms and the area around the hips. These are the places that take the most friction in daily wear and will show deterioration first.

The stretch test: does it spring back?

This is one of the most reliable physical tests and takes five seconds. Gently stretch a small section of the fabric between your hands, then release it. Good quality cashmere will spring back into its original shape almost immediately. Lower grade cashmere, or a blend with synthetic fibres, will stay stretched or take much longer to recover. While you have it stretched, also look through the fabric. The tighter and more consistent the knit, the better the garment will hold its shape over time and resist developing holes.

The pilling test: understanding what pilling actually means

This one is widely misunderstood. All cashmere pills to some degree. That is not a defect, it is a property of the fibre. What matters is when and how much. Run your palm briskly over the surface of the garment a few times. If little balls of fibre form immediately, within seconds of rubbing, that tells you the yarn contains a high proportion of shorter fibres, which is a sign of lower quality. Quality cashmere, spun from longer fibres, pills slowly. The pills it does develop stay soft and can be brushed away with a cashmere comb rather than hardening into rough bobbles that have to be cut off.

When buying secondhand, you will sometimes encounter a piece that has already pilled. The question to ask is: is the pilling surface level and even, suggesting it has simply been worn and can be restored with a good lint shaver? Or is the pilling aggressive and dense, suggesting the original fibre quality was poor? A well worn but high quality piece is often worth buying and restoring. A heavily pilled piece from a low grade fibre is not.

The burn test: the most definitive check you can do

If you have any remaining doubt about whether a piece is genuinely cashmere or a synthetic fake, the burn test settles it. Pull a single thread or a few loose fibres from an interior seam where it will not be visible. Take them somewhere safe and ventilated, away from anything flammable. Hold the fibres over a lighter flame.

Here is what genuine cashmere does: it burns slowly, curling away from the flame. It smells unmistakably of singed hair, the same smell as burning wool or any other animal protein fibre. When it goes out, it leaves a soft, crushable, powdery ash. It does not continue to burn once you remove the flame.

Here is what a synthetic fake does: it melts rather than burns. It may drip. It smells chemical or sweet, nothing like hair. It leaves a hard plastic bead rather than ash. If that is what you are holding, put the garment down and walk away.

One nuance: cashmere and wool burn in a very similar way, so the burn test cannot definitively tell cashmere apart from wool or a cashmere wool blend. What it does confirm is whether the fibre is a natural protein fibre at all, which rules out the acrylic and polyester fakes that are unfortunately common in the market.

Checking construction quality

The quality of a cashmere garment is not only about the fibre. How it is put together matters enormously for how long it will last.

Seams and linking

Cashmere sweaters are typically knitted in separate panels that are then joined. High quality knitwear uses a technique called linking, where the panels are joined stitch by stitch using pure cashmere thread. When done well, the seam is almost invisible from the outside. Turn the garment inside out and look at the seams. If the join is smooth, flat and uses matching thread that you cannot easily see, that is a good sign. If the panels are simply stitched together with an overlocked seam using a contrasting or thicker thread, the construction quality is lower.

The neck label

A small but useful tell. Look at the neck label. Is it sitting flat and correctly positioned, or is it baggy, twisted or pulling away from the fabric? A label that has gone baggy often means the neckline itself has stretched, which happens more readily in lower quality knitwear. It sounds minor but it correlates surprisingly well with overall construction quality.

Cuffs and hem

Check the ribbing on the cuffs and the hem. These areas take a lot of stress and stretch over time. The ribbing should still have elasticity and spring back when stretched. Cuffs that are permanently stretched out or flared are difficult to restore and reduce the wearable life of the piece significantly.

Specific things to check when buying secondhand

Buying a used cashmere piece requires a few extra checks beyond what you would do with new stock. Work through these before you commit:

  • Underarm area. This is the most common place for discolouration and thinning. Hold it up to the light and look carefully. Yellowing from antiperspirant is very hard to remove and often permanent.
  • Collar and cuffs. These pick up body oils over time. Light greying around the collar is sometimes washable. Heavy discolouration is not.
  • Front panels. Look for staining down the front, which can happen from food or drink. In a shop you can ask the seller to show you the full front in good light. Online, ask for specific photos if the listing shots are ambiguous.
  • Moth damage. This is the nightmare scenario. Small holes that are not at seams or high friction points can indicate moth activity. A single small hole is sometimes repairable by a specialist. Multiple small holes, or holes clustered in the body of the garment, are a dealbreaker.
  • Smell. Real cashmere absorbs odours readily. A musty or strongly perfumed piece is not necessarily ruined, a proper wash can often sort it, but a smell of damp or mildew can indicate storage damage to the fibres themselves.

Which brands are worth looking for in the secondhand market

Not all cashmere labels are equal. Some brands have built their entire reputation on fibre quality and construction, and those are the names to prioritise when you are scrolling through secondhand listings. Here are the ones I look for personally:

  • Johnstons of Elgin (Scotland). One of the oldest cashmere mills in the world. Consistently excellent fibre quality and construction. A fantastic secondhand find.
  • Pringle of Scotland. Heritage Scottish brand with strong quality standards. Very collectable secondhand.
  • Ballantyne (Scotland/Italy). Beloved by menswear enthusiasts. Made in Scotland with high grade fibre. Worth paying a little more for secondhand.
  • Gran Sasso (Italy). Italian cashmere at a high standard. Less well known than some but consistently good quality.
  • Loro Piana. The benchmark luxury producer. Secondhand Loro Piana cashmere holds its value and quality exceptionally well.
  • Jaeger (older pieces). The vintage Jaeger cashmere from the 1980s and 1990s is genuinely excellent. More recent production is variable.
  • N.Peal. British brand with strong quality credentials and loyal following in the secondhand market.

Brands to approach with more caution: fast fashion and mass market "cashmere" from large volume retailers. Even when labelled 100% cashmere, these pieces often use Grade C fibre, single ply construction and shorter staple lengths that result in heavy pilling and a short lifespan. They can still be a reasonable purchase at a low enough price, but go in with realistic expectations.

Fair prices: what should secondhand cashmere cost?

Price is a useful sanity check in the secondhand market, just as it is for new cashmere. Here is a rough guide to what I consider fair value in euros:

  • Basic or unknown brand, 100% cashmere, good condition: €15 to €35. Acceptable if the physical tests pass. Do not pay more without a clear brand indicator.
  • Mid tier heritage brand (Jaeger, N.Peal, older John Lewis own label), excellent condition: €35 to €70. Worth it if the construction and feel hold up.
  • Top tier heritage brand (Johnstons, Pringle, Ballantyne, Gran Sasso), excellent condition: €70 to €120. Very fair value compared to new retail prices of €300 or more.
  • Loro Piana or comparable luxury, excellent condition: €120 to €250 and sometimes more. Still a significant saving on new retail, and the quality genuinely justifies the price.

If a piece claims to be pure cashmere from a heritage brand and is priced under €20, be more sceptical than usual, not because bargains never happen, but because the label is worth verifying with particular care. Conversely, a high price on its own is never proof of quality. Run the tests regardless.

How to care for secondhand cashmere once you buy it

Getting the piece home is half the job. Cashmere requires specific care to stay in good condition, and a lot of secondhand pieces have suffered from previous owners not knowing this.

  • Wash by hand or on a wool cycle in cold water. Never hot water, never a standard machine cycle. Hot water causes irreversible shrinkage and fibre damage.
  • Use a gentle wool or cashmere specific detergent. A small amount goes a long way.
  • Do not wring or twist. Press the water out gently and reshape the garment by hand while damp.
  • Dry flat, never on a hanger. Hanging a wet cashmere sweater will stretch the shoulders permanently and distort the shape.
  • Store folded, not hung. For the same reason. And store with cedar blocks or lavender to deter moths.
  • Use a cashmere comb or fine lint shaver for pilling. Do this regularly on a low quality setting to keep the surface looking clean. It is not damage, it is maintenance.

A piece that has been badly stored but is otherwise good quality cashmere can often be fully revived with a careful cold hand wash and a gentle comb. I have brought back some beautiful pieces that looked rough on the hanger.

If the broader topic of spotting quality in secondhand wool based garments interests you, my guide on how to spot quality in a secondhand wool coat covers many similar principles in a different context and is worth reading alongside this one.

Frequently asked questions

How can I tell if cashmere is real or fake without a burn test?

The most reliable non destructive checks are the label (look for "100% cashmere" with no vague language), the touch test (genuine cashmere feels soft but never slippery, with a slight resistance between your fingers), and the stretch test (quality cashmere springs back into shape immediately after being gently stretched). None of these are as definitive as the burn test, but together they give you a strong indication. If the piece fails two or more of these checks, trust your instincts and walk away.

Is pilling a sign that cashmere is fake?

No. All cashmere pills to some degree, including high quality pieces. The difference is in when and how much. Good quality cashmere made from long fibres pills slowly, and the pills stay soft and can be removed with a cashmere comb. Low quality or blended cashmere pills heavily and almost immediately, within the first few wears, and the pills tend to be harder and more difficult to remove. So pilling alone does not mean fake, but heavy immediate pilling strongly suggests poor fibre quality or a blend.

What does ply mean and does it matter when buying secondhand cashmere?

Ply refers to how many strands of yarn are twisted together to form the finished thread. Single ply cashmere is lighter but more fragile, more prone to thinning and holes over time. Two ply cashmere uses two strands twisted together, giving the garment more body, durability and warmth. For everyday wear, two ply is the better choice and is worth prioritising when you can identify it on the label or in the product description. Three ply is warmer and more robust still, though less common in the secondhand market.

What is a fair price to pay for secondhand cashmere?

It depends on the brand, condition and fibre quality. For an unknown or basic brand in good condition, €15 to €35 is reasonable. For a mid tier heritage brand like older Jaeger or N.Peal in excellent condition, €35 to €70 is fair. For top heritage producers like Johnstons of Elgin, Pringle of Scotland or Ballantyne, €70 to €120 is still excellent value compared to new retail prices. Loro Piana and similar luxury producers can justify €120 to €250 secondhand and still represent a significant saving on retail. Anything claiming to be pure cashmere from a reputable brand at under €20 warrants extra scrutiny on the label and physical tests.

Can moth damage in a cashmere sweater be repaired?

Sometimes, yes. A single small hole in an isolated location can often be invisibly repaired by a skilled knitwear mender or a specialist invisible mending service, and it is worth doing for a genuinely high quality piece. Multiple holes, or holes spread across the body of the garment, are a different matter. The cost of professional repair quickly exceeds the value of the piece, and the structural integrity of the fabric may be compromised. In those cases it is better to pass and find another piece.

Which secondhand cashmere brands are most worth buying?

The names I look for first are Johnstons of Elgin, Pringle of Scotland, Ballantyne, Gran Sasso, Loro Piana and N.Peal. These brands have consistently high fibre and construction standards, and their pieces tend to hold up well even after years of wear. Older Jaeger pieces from the 1980s and 1990s are also excellent. I am more cautious with high volume or mass market "cashmere" even when labelled 100% cashmere, as the fibre grade is often low and the pieces pill heavily. Brand reputation is not a substitute for the physical tests, but it is a very useful starting filter when you are scanning a lot of listings quickly.

Buying secondhand cashmere is one of the most rewarding things you can do as a conscious buyer. The pieces are out there: proper heritage knitwear at a fraction of original retail, made to last decades and only getting better with age. You just need to know what you are looking at. I hope this guide gives you exactly that confidence. If you want to see the kind of quality pieces we look for and curate at Revaleur, come and browse the collection. Every piece has been chosen with the same criteria I have laid out here.

Back to blog
Shipping & Return
14 days return policy
Authenticity Verified
Saving 2,700 Liters of Water